Early adopters find new niches for 16-slice CT
Attracted by cardiac potential, users discover places beyond the
heart
By: Deborah R. Dakins
As the technique of choice for most cardiovascular cases, multidetector CT is
earning accolades from early adopters of the latest 16-slice scanners. And while
the device has been lauded for its cardiac imaging potential, users at sites
around the country are identifying new CT frontiers beyond the heart. What some
call a quantum leap in quality means that imaging will be faster and better in
all parts of the body.
"The beauty of these new machines is that there are always areas that we
don't anticipate," said Dr. Joseph Lee, chair of radiology at the University of
North Carolina, Chapel Hill.
Often overlooked in the excitement about 16-slice CT's cardiac imaging
capability is its value in trauma patients. The greatly accelerated diagnostic
workup-a complete survey with 1.25-mm slices from head to pelvis completed in
less than one minute of scanning-is the biggest clinical advantage of the new
systems, according to Dr. Freidrich Knollmann, a professor of radiology at
Humboldt University in Berlin.
The rapidity with which scans are conducted means that total time in the
imaging suite for a typical complete trauma study is less than 10 minutes.
Moreover, the accelerated protocol comprises all typical complications and has
greatly improved diagnostic workflow in severe trauma patients.
 |
| Long Beach researchers reconstructed this image of a 95%
stenosis in the right internal carotid artery. (Provided by J. Renner) |
"At these fast speeds, we are increasingly able to convince our trauma
surgeons that part of the conventional radiographic workup can either be delayed
until after CT or replaced by the initial CT scan," he said.
Humboldt operates the largest university hospital system in Europe, the
three-campus Charite, with a total of 2500 beds. The newest of these, Charite
Virchow-Klinikum, was completed in 1988 and now boasts a 16-slice scanner.
Installation of the scanner prompted workflow changes at Charite
Virchow-notably, a transition to soft-copy reading.
"We automatically transfer all CT studies to a separate workstation capable
of advanced 3D reconstruction and then review the images in cine mode, directly
hopping to 3D reconstructions depending on the clinical problem and the axial
image findings," Knollmann said.
Because Charite Virchow has no systemwide PACS installed, this process is
used to speed integration of 3D techniques into the conventional reading
process. For documentation, hard copies are generated with a larger slice
thickness only, along with selected findings from the soft-copy reading
session.
"We try to integrate 3D workup into our reading routine and are teaching
residents how to use 3D tools to ensure that the diagnosis is not delayed," he
said.
In both clinical and research projects, the new device offers dramatic
potential. Clinically, the university has noted advantages ranging from cardiac
investigations to an array of vascular applications. Specific benefits have also
been found in pediatric CT and virtual endoscopy using 1.25-mm collimation. The
same mode is beneficial for peripheral arterial runoff studies as well.
In research mode, 16-slice CT allows submillimeter imaging of entire anatomic
compartments within a single breath-hold and with a single contrast bolus,
Knollmann said.
"Many of the submillimeter protocols are still evolving, and the techniques
leave ample room for future innovation and research," he said.
PEDIATRIC ADVANTAGE
Sixteen-slice CT offers numerous potential benefits for pediatric imagers,
including dramatically improved resolution of the small anatomical structures
found in infants and children. Along with the ability to scan faster, thus
reducing the need for sedation in some children, resolution was a key selling
point to Dr. John Renner, medical director of radiology at Long Beach Memorial
Medical Center in Long Beach, CA.
The 750-bed hospital is linked to 200-bed Miller Children's Hospital, and the
newly installed Toshiba Aquilion 16 scanner is the first multidetector unit
onsite.
"We wanted to prove that we could scan with reduced dose, quicker scans, less
sedation, and more accurate studies in children," Renner said. "That was one
selling point. The other was the potential to perform CT angiography for
peripheral and coronary applications."
 |
| University of Michigan researchers used 16-slice
technology to obtain images of the mesenteric vessels in a patient with right
lower quadrant pain (left) and the intrahepatic system in a living potential
liver donor. (Provided by J. Platt) |
The decision to purchase the scanner was just one step in a long line of
firsts for Long Beach. The hospital's PACS was newly installed in September,
just a month before the 16-slice scanner arrived.
The new scanner immediately assumed the lion's share of the more than 100 CT
scans performed daily at the two facilities and is being pressed into service
for a wide range of studies, according to Renner. The investment has proved so
successful that Memorial has already purchased and scheduled delivery of a
second 16-slice unit.
"Multidetector technology is a quantum leap forward from where we were
before," he said. "We can do so much more, in fact, we are not even sure of all
the applications yet. It's almost like learning CT all over again."
Based on the site's experience switching from nonspiral to spiral CT in the
mid-1990s, Renner expects scan demand and volume to increase with the faster
thin-slice device.
"Once word is out that you have this technology, people want to use it," he
said. "When we switched to helical scanning, our volume went up threefold over
the next two years. Now we expect it to take another jump-possibly by as much as
25%."
One unanticipated challenge is the amount of time spent by workstation-bound
physicians processing 16-slice data of angiographic studies.
While more time has been spent on back-end processing, throughput is
unquestionably faster.
"The fact that we can do some pediatric patients with little or no sedation
has clearly improved our throughput and operational efficiency," he said.
Renner is eager to tackle CT coronary angiography, a clinical frontier that
had been out of his reach.
"While our outpatient facility did have a four-slice unit on which we could
do coronary calcium screening, we really could not perform good coronary
angiography," he said. "Nor could we do good CT abdomen, pelvis, or runoff
angios before-it was just too much coverage. Now we can image with 1-mm slices
in less than 30 seconds, from the diaphragm to the ankles, with very good
quality."
20/20 VISION
In the 20 years since he penned the first textbook on CT, Lee has seen his
share of new developments in radiology. But few are as exciting as 16-slice
CT.
"As a resident in St. Louis during the era of the EMI 5000, I literally
witnessed the birth of body CT," Lee said. "Most of my current faculty are too
young to even know what the EMI 5000 was-18 seconds for a single slice, then two
and a half minutes for reconstruction of one image. Twenty years ago, no one
could have envisioned what we would be able to do."
 |
| Using 0.5-mm imaging, a 16-slice scanner can depict
tendons in the ankle. (Provided by Toshiba) |
Today, six months after installing a 16-slice scanner, Lee and colleagues are
using it for everything from vascular imaging to bread-and-butter studies.
"Sixteen-slice is very straightforward for all of the vascular structures,
pulmonary embolism, abdominal aortic aneurysms, and intracranial vessels," he
said. "But the speed of 16-slice also makes it excellent for trauma cases,
C-spines, and musculoskeletal indications."
Indeed, the quality of thin-slice imaging could bolster CT as a substitute
for MR in musculoskeletal imaging, particularly joint imaging, where spatial
resolution is crucial. In addition, because 16-slice provides good resolution
equally in all three imaging planes, patients with musculoskeletal injuries may
not have to be placed in painful positions during scanning.
In addition to these established uses, Lee has set his sights on identifying
and exploring some of the lesser known frontiers of 16-slice CT.
"We're actively trying to figure out various aspects of the body where people
have not been able to use CT as effectively," he said. "Just like a fine bottle
of wine, our research targets are not quite mature enough to release. There are
lots of exciting things going on and lots of ideas at all the sites that now
have 16-slice. Everybody will pick a niche and explore it."
In the near term, having 16-slice on hand means that UNC is able to tackle
more complex clinical cases than in the past, particularly in the vascular
realm. In a department already well known for its endovascular grafts and
interventional and neuroradiology procedures, UNC has made headway in collecting
data to establish 16-slice CT as a substitute for invasive preoperative imaging
of intracranial aneurysms.
"One of these days, we may not need to do angiograms before embolizing
intracranial aneurysms," Lee said. "It still needs to be proven, but the
diagnosis is straightforward, and the quality is very good."
To prepare for 16-slice installation, UNC rescaled the resident PACS and
added dedicated 3D workstations. The department has a protocol for image
storage, wherein only the reconstructed data are saved.
"If we saved the raw data, we would literally saturate our PACS," he
said.
Having seen the birth and gradual evolution of CT over the years, Lee
believes that the modality is finally giving MRI a run for its money.
"Because of the vascular applications, the musculoskeletal, C-spines, and
trauma uses, 16-slice is really phenomenal," he said. "There is now a real horse
race between MRI and CT. While CT has always been an anatomical technique, it is
beginning to verge on functional imaging status."
PLACES IN THE HEART
For months prior to installation of a 16-slice scanner at the University of
Michigan, Ann Arbor, Dr. Joel Platt had heard all the hyperbole about the
dazzling cardiac capabilities of the new device. But he wasn't prepared for the
hype to be true.
"When we were told that this might be the cardiac machine everyone has been
waiting for, we were skeptical," said Platt, a professor of radiology who
specializes in body CT. "We did a few cases, and we're not skeptical
anymore."
Platt had logged thousands of studies on the university's four- and
eight-slice machines and thought he knew what to expect.
"Sixteen slices really seems to make a difference," he said. "At least in the
case of our vendor, it seems to be the first foray into isotropic CT
imaging."
Other early adopters have noted how the thin slices create excellent spatial
resolution in all three imaging planes. The resulting isotropic voxels of
16-slice CT capture fine detail and create 3D renderings of arteries that wind
in and out of the imaging plane.
"I can tell a case that was performed using a 16-slice scanner from one
acquired with a four- or eight-slice scanner just by the way the images look,"
Platt said. "It's a noticeable difference. That surprised us. The other surprise
was that it really could do heart vessels and very small vessels, such as the
kidney and liver."
He was also pleased by the scanner's ability to deliver many of the cardiac
imaging requirements needed to challenge invasive imaging with a noninvasive
form. The value of the noninvasive form remains to be seen, however, and he
expects it to be the topic of studies done over the next several years.
Platt is hopeful that 16-slice is not just another technological benchmark
for CT, a critical-but not final-upgrade. Even though the device has been lauded
for its cardiac capabilities, he sees much more potential for it. Sixteen-slice
is applicable to numerous vascular applications beyond the heart.
"In the old days, we were taught that you had to choose between coverage and
resolution, because you could not have both with CT," he said. "You can have
them both now."
Ms. Dakins is a freelance writer in Ben Lomond, CA.
|