|
BY GREG
FREIHERR
Much
faster scanning prompts manufacturers to seek ways to handle an increasing
flow of information
Speed
has become the most coveted characteristic for MRI and CT developers.
Rapid data capture and processing are allowing both cross-sectional modalities
to address clinical applications otherwise outside their scope. These
technologies will only reach their potential, however, with advances in
automation, interfaces, and image display, as the enormous quantity of
data being delivered threatens to hinder rather than enhance productivity.
Exhibits
at the RSNA meeting will reflect these technical challenges. Products
will be present in abundance, but unlike past years will not be stars
of the show. More highly featured will be clinical applications, particularly
cardiac imaging and angiography, as vendors have concluded that, for now,
it is new clinical capabilities that motivate prospective buyers.
Exhibit-goers
will be deluged with information about coronary calcium scoringan
indicator of heart attack risk that Imatron pioneered with its electron-beam
CT. The new generation of multislice CT scanners can deliver these measurements
and much more. GE, Siemens, Picker, and Toshiba are grooming their multislice
scanners to rival x-ray angiography, which is still the gold standard
of cardiac imaging.
Multislice
could really open up cardiology as one of the key strategic directions
for CT, said John Sandstrom, Ph.D., director of strategic marketing
and CT at Siemens Medical Systems. There is a renewed interest in
making sure that we drive applications further and faster.
WHAT
TO LOOK FOR
At this
RSNA show, vendors will move beyond calcium plaques to demonstrate that
CT can detect soft plaques as well. In other cardiac highlights, GE will
demonstrate how its LightSpeed QX/i can record myocardial perfusion. And
a stent planning package from GE will measure vessels to size stents before
intervention. The key to these new capabilities is innovative techniques
that deliver temporal resolution equivalent to what can be achieved with
a 160-msec revolution.
We
might be able to get down even below that before we get to the RSNA,
said Ken Denison, manager of global CT for GE.
The technology
that will produce these results is still a work in progress, although
commercial shipments could begin next year, Denison said.
Cardiac
imaging has not only eluded the grasp of CT until now, but it has also
lacked the MRI one-stop shop approach. For the most part, cardiac packages
released by vendors were the equivalent of todays PC-based speech
recognition tools: a novelty worth talking about but not worth using.
At the RSNA meeting, vendors will present optimized MRI systems worthy
of both.
The Siemens
Sonata platform is a standout, offering a comprehensive cardiac examination
that includes perfusion, morphologic, and ventricular studies. Brand-new
at the Siemens booth will be a method for characterizing plaque, but Siemens
postprocessing capabilities will likely make the greatest impression.
The German company has groomed its Sonata to provide the staples of myocardial
analysisejection fraction and myocardial thickness by heart regionwhile
providing rapid three-dimensional reconstruction techniques, including
fly-throughs.
There
will be a tremendous emphasis on postprocessing, said John D. Pavlidis,
MR division manager at Siemens. We are determined to provide a comprehensive
cardiac exam.
Picker International
will unveil contrast-enhanced MR angiography enhancements, including automatic
bolus tracking software and a new stepping table. Both will be integrated
with an interactive user-interface contrast injector control, as well
as a new 12-channel phased-array peripheral MRA coil.
Pickers
flagship 1.5-tesla Eclipse will feature the new PD350 gradient system
offering a 30 mtesla/m peak and 120 mtesla/m/sec slew rate. The new gradients
should provide improved perfusion and diffusion imaging of the brain.
The ultimate
expression of cardiac and brain imaging might be seen at very high field
strength. GE will expand last years offerings at the RSNA meeting,
showcasing its VH/i (very high field/interactive) MRI program. Other vendors
will offer their own 3-tesla systems.
Siemens will
showcase its dedicated 3-tesla brain scanner, the Magnetom Allegra, and
announce a 3-tesla platform for whole-body imaging. Both systems are based
on Magnetom Symphony components, including active shielding to minimize
siting requirements.
Picker International
plans to describe its program for developing 3-tesla systems in hopes
of attracting clinical partners. The companys purchase earlier this
year of Surrey Medical Imaging Systems of Surrey, U.K, a premier manufacturer
of very high field systems, should provide a market advantage. The plan
is to add a standard 3-tesla system, probably optimized for neurologic
and vascular imaging, to the Picker product line, which currently ranges
from 0.23- to 1.5-tesla. Picker engineers are working on a prototype,
although it probably will not be ready for the RSNA exhibit.
MULTISLICE
PROGRESS
The multislice
revolution, barely more than a year old, will come to fruition at this
years meeting with GE, Siemens, Picker, and Toshiba America all
showing scanners capable of generating four slices with each gantry rotation.
Philips plans to release a premium product, the CT Vision Secura, that
will be upgradable to multislice. The Secura will hit the market when
the detector becomes available, possibly as early as next year. Having
the basic platform allows engineers to concentrate on optimizing the specific
components necessary for multislice imaging.
We
are working on the reconstruction and data management technology, the
detector and image quality specifications, said Janet Collins, Ph.D.,
North American business director for Philips CT.
The Holland-based
company will introduce a mid-tier system called the CT Vision Aura at
the RSNA meeting. This product will share the same functionality as Secura,
but with a less powerful x-ray system and slower gantry rotation of one
second, versus 0.7 second for the Secura.
Toshiba will
be exhibiting its multislice detector for the first time this year. Each
of the four detector rows in the center is 0.5 mm wide. The other 30 rows
(15 on each side) are 1-mm wide. Regardless of the number of detector
rows, however, the Toshiba detector delivers only four slices, just as
its competitors do. The limiting factor is the data acquisition system
(DAS), said Charles Corogenes, director of Toshibas CT business
unit.
If
we ever get to the point where we have a DAS thats cheap enough
and fast enough to handle the data, we could have 32 slices with the present
detector, Corogenes said. If we did it with todays technology,
(the scanner) would have to be huge and it would be very expensive.
Toshiba will
emphasize the practical side of multislice. The company plans to introduce
a high-performance fluoroscopy package for the fully outfitted Aquillion.
With
multislice, you get a wider slab of data to look at, Corogenes said.
That helps with needle orientation.
With single-slice
scanners, the needle tip easily moves beyond the plane being imaged. The
ultimate solution is to expand data processing to offer 3-D reconstructions
in real-time, he said.
Aquillion
was released in fall 1998, but only in a single-slice configuration. The
Japanese company hoped to sell the single-slice Aquillion on its mechanical
prowessthe ability to do half-second rotationsand the promise
of multislice to come. More than 20 units were sold to U.S. customers
and are prospects for this upgrade, which will soon be available. Meanwhile,
Aquillions configured with multislice technology have begun shipping.
Toshiba will spotlight this system at the RSNA show, along with a companion
product called Asteion.
The $200,000
price difference between the two systems is reflected in the Asteions
less powerful generator and x-ray tube. (Toshiba declined to give a list
price for either system, noting only that they would be competitive with
similar products.) The big difference, however, is in rotation speed:
three-quarters of a second for Asteion, and a half-second for Aquillion.
Both can handle multislice scanning if outfitted with the right detector.
Siemens is
developing a similar family for its customers. It will unveil two new
CT scanners: the Emotion, featuring an 800-msec rotation, and Balance,
a one-second rotation scanner. Both products feature advantages in siting,
as the electronics that would have otherwise been put in cabinets are
packed in the gantries, which themselves are thinner than in previous
models. The helical products can be upgraded to the high-performance Somatom
Plus and multislice.
GE will debut
a new product, HiSpeed ZX/i, which will be plugged in below the premier
LightSpeed, but features high-performance single-slice scanning at a competitive
price point, according to the company. GE will also introduce a low-tier
scanner for overseas markets and U.S. physicians offices. The price,
around $200,000, is noteworthy for a helical scanner.
BETTER
AND FASTER MRI
GE and Siemens
will be brandishing the power of interactivity, much as they did at last
years meeting when both focused on real-time imaging as the means
to new clinical pathways. GE spokesperson Tom Beckman said only that the
company would have a lot of exciting things that well be unveiling
for the first time at the show.
Siemens
was more specific. It will unveil a neurofunctional imaging package that
automatically corrects for patient motion in real-time. The new package
fully automates both the acquisition and postprocessing of functional
imaging, according to Pavlidis.
The computer
figures in the orientation of the slice when determining how to handle
errant data. If the motion could cause gross artifact, the computer rejects
the data. If the motion is subtle, algorithms are triggered to compensate.
You
can see in real-time the evolution of data and how the system takes into
account possible motion correction due to involuntary patient motion,
he said.
A key feature
at the Philips booth will be a multi-array technology called Sense (sensitivity
encoding). The work-in-progress uses several coils to simultaneously measure
the same body region, correcting for aliasing effects and cutting measurement
time dramatically, depending on the number of Sense coils employed. Five
coils used in cardiac studies, for example, render a four-fold reduction
in scan time. Early studies have produced real-time imaging sequences
at 40 frames/second.
Sense
is very exciting because it will speed up imaging on all applications,
not only cardiac, but neuro, angio, and abdominal imaging, said
Guido P. Stomp, Philips business unit director of MR marketing.
Toshiba
America will introduce a new high-field product designed specifically
for patient comfort. The 1.5-tesla Excelart Pianissimo features a compact
magnet with a patient opening of 65.5 cm, the largest of any commercial
system, according to Martin Forbes, director of MR sales and marketing.
Additionally, system gradients offer up to 90% noise reduction compared
to other high-field systems, he said.
When
we demonstrated this noise reduction to the market survey group, which
comprised doctors, technologists, and administrators, 90% thought it would
be a significant benefit to the patient and 80% thought it would give
them a superior presence in their own markets, Forbes said.
Toshibas
earlier high-field system, the Visart, can be retrofitted to the Excelart
configuration, he said. Older models, however, will require a magnet upgrade.
Toshiba is
best known for its open superconducting system, Opart. New for the 0.35-tesla
product will be a motorized table, an interface that allows operation
at the tableside, an enhanced monitor, and coils that provide not only
improved image quality but better access to the patient. One of the new
coils, a work-in-progress designed for breast imaging, will work with
a biopsy gun. Partly driving the development of these devices is interventional
MRI, whose potential Forbes describes as huge but largely unrealized.
Interventional
imaging will be a highlight for Pickers open MR system, Outlook
Proview, which will be outfitted with a basic package for MRI-guided procedures,
including an in-room console and monitor, dedicated protocols for tracking
biopsy needles in real time, and special coils. A second package, built
around optical tracking technology, will include an infrared camera, as
well as tools with integrated LED trackers.
With
this, we will always know where the tip of the needle is so we can automatically
collect data at the tip of the needle, said Mike Vitagliano, MR
marketing manager.
One of the
pioneers of open MRI and a major proponent of interventional applications,
Hitachi Medical Systems America, will bolster the capability of its flagship
Airis II system. The company will expand its product line of phased-array
coils. One of the primary clinical targets will be orthopedic applications,
particularly for the shoulder. But Hitachis most impressive works
to be featured are still months from commercialization. These are echo-planar
imaging (EPI), diffusion-weighted brain scanning made possible by EPI,
fat-water separation, and contrast-enhanced MR angiography, all of which
are currently seen primarily on high-field systems. Getting these techniques
to run on a mid-field open system was not easy, said Sheldon Shaeffer,
vice president and general manager of MRI at Hitachi.
You
need a high homogeneity magnet, high slew rate gradients, and a computer
system fast enough to handle the data coming in, he said. So
we had to optimize all the components of our MRI system.
|