 |
When
it comes to radiation, Hollywood is full of Baloneum
Patients
pick up some of their fears along with their popcorn at the movie
theater
By Bradley M. Tipler, M.D.
|
In the November
issue of DI, Anne Scheck does a nice job writing about Hollywoods
treatment of radiology. For years I have lectured on the slightly broader
topic of "Radiation and the Movies." Since Roentgen discovered
x-rays, and the Lumière brothers gave the first public showing
of their cinematographe in 1895, the two fields have continually interacted.
Now, over a century later, Americans idolize the movies, and have a phobia
about radiation. Maybe I picked the wrong field.
Some might
argue with my choice of the word "phobia." But how often have
you seen a pregnant woman who drives a car, smokes, and drinks, refuse
an x-ray when she presents to the ER short of breath? Not only is she
scared of "the risks," but so are most of the people taking
care of her. Even radiology department personnel get anxious, often
burying the patient in lead aprons. Why this unreasonable and persistent
fear? I believe movies deserve the blame.
The first
two "movies" featuring x-rays were released in 1897. Both
were one-minute silent films. The British "X-rays" featured
a couple courting on a park bench. Someone shines an x-ray on them and
two skeletons are then seen courting. "Les Rayons Roentgen"
has a client step in front of an x-ray; his skeleton steps out and then
back in. The client then refuses to pay the operator and a fight ensues.
People have always liked our charges.
Until the
20s, radiation was generally used as a gimmick, allowing for site
gags and surprises, not surprisingly, because early movies were little
else. The idea of a story or plot arose only later. From the 20s
to the 40s, the "death ray" and the mad scientist grew
in popularity. The popular image of what kind of people work with radiation,
what we do with it, and how radiation can affect your life was beginning
to form. Unfortunately, it doesnt go uphill from here.
In 1945
the first atom bombs were exploded. Among the many side effects, the
publics perception of science, scientists, and radiation would
change forever. The late 40s and 50s saw an avalanche of
radiation movies. Along with humans, just about every insect, animal,
and dinosaur was magnified, shrunk, or mutated by radiation in the movies.
The 50s
and 60s saw the rise of the radiation thriller, often featuring
an evil scientist and the threat of a massive radiation event, which
would "end the world as we know it." James Bond flicks and
his imitators often use this story line.
While used
before, the 70s brought an onslaught of movies using radiation
events to set the stage. A big nuclear war allows the moviemakers to
create any kind of world they want. Also, since the 70s, the theme
that people who work with and control radiation cannot be trusted has
blossomed. "The China Syndrome" is typical of this motif,
and its coincidental release at the time of the Three Mile Island nonevent
essentially ended the development of nuclear power in this country.
Cars kill
50,000 Americans a year, but we grew up seeing them glamorized in the
movies. Fires kill 8000 people a year. Do we calculate the risk of matches
by extrapolating from the effects on people who survived a napalm bomb?
Since childhood you could mentally picture a pirate ship, the inside
of a U-boat, cowboys fighting Indians and hundreds of other things you
have never really seenall thanks to the movies. Most Americans
mental image of radiation is just as real and just as accurate, thanks
to the movies.
DR.
TIPLER is a private-practice radiologist in Staunton, VA. He
can be reached by fax at 540/332-4491 or by e-mail at btipler@cfw.com.