Those of us who recognize our frailties -- the prejudices and biases that creep almost imperceptibly into our decision making -- would welcome a quantifiable means for ensuring that those decisions are best made. Last month, prosecutors successfully convinced a court in Mumbai, India, that a scan that records activity in distinct areas of the brain can be such a measure. On the basis of a “Brain Electrical Oscillations Signature” test, the court convicted and sentenced to life in prison a 24-year-old woman for murdering her fiancé.
Those of us who recognize our frailties -- the prejudices and biases that creep almost imperceptibly into our decision making -- would welcome a quantifiable means for ensuring that those decisions are best made. Last month, prosecutors successfully convinced a court in Mumbai, India, that a scan that records activity in distinct areas of the brain can be such a measure. On the basis of a "Brain Electrical Oscillations Signature" test, the court convicted and sentenced to life in prison a 24-year-old woman for murdering her fiancé.When specific crime details were read out loud, 32 electrodes placed on the accused woman's head recorded incriminating activity in parts of the brain that are believed to be associated with memory. It was the first time an Indian court had accepted brain scan results as proof of guilt. Previously, the courts had accepted such results only as corroborating evidence of a criminal act.The case is both fascinating and frightening. It exemplifies how far technology has come and how willing people are to accept its use.For those who just felt a shiver, you can shrug it off as a strange twist in a world where strange things get more than their share of attention. On its website, La Jolla, CA-based No Lie MRI claims it "provides unbiased methods for the detection of deception and other information stored in the brain." How? By using functional MRI, which enables the firm to measure "intent, prior knowledge, and deception."
Need a second opinion? Try Cephos. The Tyngsboro, MA-based company tries to make good on its motto "When Truth Matters" through expert DNA testing, private detectives, and -- you guessed it -- fMRI. Click on a tab for the "legal admissibility" of fMRI, and you'll find the following assertions:
Cephos claims that the ability of fMRI to distinguish between truth and lies has been documented in 18 peer-reviewed, published papers. The company does not list the titles of these papers, but it's clear that research supporting the use of fMRI as a lie detector technology has been reported at least since the 2004 RSNA meeting.
Given the history of fMRI and our predilection as a society to adopt high technology from everything from PCs to cruise control, it's surprising that more companies like Cephos and No Lie MRI have not popped up. If fMRI proves effective at detecting lies, and its use is accepted in the U.S. legal system, this technology could have an enormous social impact, equivalent to DNA testing but potentially much more intrusive. And this is only the beginning. How it might be used outside the legal system -- by the intelligence community, for example -- in combination with morally suspect information-gathering techniques conjures an Orwellian picture.While truth is a laudable goal, it is mitigated by how it is obtained. Now rather than later is the time for the imaging community to consider its role in this process, both as developer and user of such lie detection technologies.
FDA Clears Enhanced MRI-Guided Laser Ablation System
June 5th 2025An alternative to an open neurosurgical approach, the Visualase V2 MRI-Guided Laser Ablation System reportedly utilizes laser interstitial thermal therapy (LITT) for targeted soft tissue ablation in patients with brain tumors and focal epilepsy.
Can Abbreviated MRI Have an Impact in Differentiating Intraductal Papilloma and Ductal Secretion?
June 3rd 2025For patients with inconclusive ultrasound results, abbreviated breast MRI offers comparable detection of intraductal papilloma as a full breast MRI protocol at significantly reduced times for scan acquisition and interpretation, according to a new study.
FDA Issues Expanded Pediatric Approval of MRI Contrast Agent for Lung Ventilation Assessment
June 2nd 2025Previously approved for MRI lung ventilation evaluation in adults and children 12 and older, the hyperpolarized contrast agent Xenoview can now be utilized for pediatric patients six years and older.