A CMS quality measurement for use of CT scans on emergency department patients with atraumatic headaches is not reliable, researchers found.
A CMS quality measurement for use of CT scans on emergency department patients with atraumatic headaches is not reliable, according to a study published online in the Annals of Emergency Medicine. The measurements could lead to inaccurate comparisons of imaging performance in the ED.
CT scans on patients with atraumatic headaches is increasing in EDs around the country, which has raised concerns about rising costs and exposure to radiation. To determine if the testing was appropriate, the CMS developed measure OP-15, “Use of Brain Computed Tomography in the Emergency Department for Atraumatic Headache.” However, OP-15, which was implemented in January 2012, was never field tested.
To determine the measurement’s accuracy, researchers at Brigham and Women’s Hospital in Boston, Mass., completed a retrospective record review of 748 patients, gathered from 21 EDs in the U.S., who were labeled as receiving inappropriate brain scans.
The researchers found that 83 percent of the patients who were identified as inappropriately tested actually were validly scanned; 65 percent of the scans did comply with the measures and 18 percent should not have been labeled this way to begin with.
“The CMS imaging efficacy measurement for brain CTs (OP-15) is not reliable, valid or accurate, and may produce misleading information about hospital emergency department performance,” the authors concluded.
The researchers acknowledged that while this measurement is not effective, everyone must work together to ensure proper the use of CT scans in the ED.
“Further research should focus on developing scientific evidence that could be used to better inform this measure,” said Ali Raja, MD, associate director for trauma, BWH Department of Emergency Medicine, and a co-author of the study. “Existing guidelines built around solid evidence for the appropriate use of CT for other clinical conditions could serve as a guide for the measurement of these an similar conditions.”
Stay at the forefront of radiology with the Diagnostic Imaging newsletter, delivering the latest news, clinical insights, and imaging advancements for today’s radiologists.
Study Shows Enhanced Diagnosis of Coronary Artery Stenosis with Photon-Counting CTA
July 10th 2025In a new study comparing standard resolution and ultra-high resolution modes for patients undergoing coronary CTA with photon-counting detector CT, researchers found that segment-level sensitivity and accuracy rates for diagnosing coronary artery stenosis were consistently > 89.6 percent.
Can CT-Based Deep Learning Bolster Prognostic Assessments of Ground-Glass Nodules?
June 19th 2025Emerging research shows that a multiple time-series deep learning model assessment of CT images provides 20 percent higher sensitivity than a delta radiomic model and 56 percent higher sensitivity than a clinical model for prognostic evaluation of ground-glass nodules.