The Breast Imaging Reporting and Data System for ultrasound can reliably characterize breast tumors, according to a study published in the April issue of the American Journal of Roentgenology.
The Breast Imaging Reporting and Data System for ultrasound can reliably characterize breast tumors, according to a study published in the April issue of the American Journal of Roentgenology.
Clinical data validating ultrasound's ability to differentiate benign from malignant breast lesions keep accumulating. But the modality's value for breast cancer screening remains controversial because previous attempts to devise classification systems for the modality did not provide consistent results.
Dr. Andrea S. Hong and colleagues in the radiology department at Duke University weighed the BI-RADS nomenclature that describes tumors according to their shape, orientation, margins, and several ultrasound-specific features. They found these ultrasound-based descriptors, developed by the American College of Radiology in 2003, were significantly different in malignant and benign masses.
The investigators' trial included sonograms of 403 breast lesions - 202 palpable and 201 unpalpable - from 369 patients. Each case was evaluated blindly by one of three dedicated breast radiologists, who correlated descriptions against mammography and biopsy. Histology confirmed 35% of the masses as malignant.
The ACR's ultrasound BI-RADS lexicon identified masses with spiculated margins, irregular shapes, and nonparallel orientation as having high positive predictive values (86%, 62%, and 69%, respectively). Lesions described as having high negative predictive values using the same scheme included circumscribed margins (90%), parallel orientation (78%), and oval shapes (84%). The differences in ultrasound BI-RADS features that helped identify benign from malignant masses were statistically significant (p
BI-RADS ultrasound-specific markers showing high predictive value for benign lesions included posterior acoustic enhancement (67%) and no posterior acoustic features (79%). Posterior acoustic shadowing, on the other hand, showed the highest predictive value for malignancy (52%).
Although mammography remains the imaging standard for population screening, a growing number of clinical studies agree that more powerful, widely available ultrasound technology has improved diagnosis and management of breast tumors.
As in mammography, sonographic BI-RADS descriptors showing spiculated margins suggest the occurrence of infiltrating lesions, while irregular shapes can indicate inconsistent growth and advancement of a lesion's edge. On the other hand, most lesions showing circumscribed margins or oval shapes indicating smooth uniform growth can be associated with benign tumors, the Duke researchers said.
The study had some limitations. The observers were generally not blinded to mammograms when they evaluated ultrasound results. And though blinded to biopsy, they were aware their assessments did not directly affect patient care, which might have influenced their analysis. However, long-term follow-up studies with larger population and histology samples using Duke's guidelines may provide more conclusive results, they said.
The ACR BI-RADS lexicon provides standardized terminology that facilitates accurate and consistent breast sonography and mammography reporting, investigators said.
For more information from the Diagnostic Imaging archives:
Research supports ultrasound for breast cancer screening
Breast ultrasound wins in younger women
MRI, ultrasound find larger role in staging breast cancer
The Reading Room: Racial and Ethnic Minorities, Cancer Screenings, and COVID-19
November 3rd 2020In this podcast episode, Dr. Shalom Kalnicki, from Montefiore and Albert Einstein College of Medicine, discusses the disparities minority patients face with cancer screenings and what can be done to increase access during the pandemic.
Study Finds Transvaginal Ultrasound Unreliable for Detecting Endometrial Cancer in Black Patients
July 3rd 2024Utilizing a threshold of less than 5 mm of ultrasound-measured endometrial thickness, the authors of a new study noted an 11.4 percent false-negative probability for endometrial cancer in Black patients.
New Study Shows Non-Radiologists Interpreting 28 Percent of Imaging for Medicare Patients
June 28th 2024While radiologists interpreted approximately 99 percent of all non-cardiac CT, MRI and nuclear medicine studies in hospital and emergency department settings for Medicare beneficiaries, new research shows significantly less radiologist review of cardiac imaging and office-based imaging.
FDA Clears Pocket-Sized ECG System and AI Technology for Detection of Cardiac Conditions
June 27th 2024Using a reduced leadset and deep neural network algorithms trained on more than 175 million electrocardiograms, the KAI 12L technology reportedly detects up to 35 cardiac determinations, including acute myocardial infarction.