Preliminary results from a Mayo Clinic study suggest that patients who undergo vertebroplasty may die sooner than patients with vertebral fractures who do not undergo the procedure.
Preliminary results from a Mayo Clinic study suggest that patients who undergo vertebroplasty may die sooner than patients with vertebral fractures who do not undergo the procedure.
Vertebroplasty has long been validated as a safe and effective treatment for patients with vertebral compression fractures from osteoporosis. Elderly patients, in particular, experience pain reduction and improved mobility. It remains unclear, however, whether the image-guided interventional procedure has a beneficial effect on survival.
An investigative team led by Dr. David F. Kallmes, a professor of radiology at the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, MN, sought to answer this lingering question. Kallmes and colleagues compared survival rates of patients treated for vertebral fractures with vertebroplasty with those who had not undergone the procedure. The investigators were bewildered when the preliminary analysis of the data showed that vertebroplasty recipients had a significantly reduced life expectancy when compared with untreated patients.
"After seeing these results, it doesn't make any sense to us," said coauthor Dr. Robert J. McDonald from Mayo's Medical Scientist Training Program.
McDonald released the preliminary findings at the 2008 RSNA meeting in Chicago.
The investigators tracked survival and clinical outcomes, including pain, pre- and postoperative mobility, and drug use, in a study group of 518 patients with osteoporotic vertebral compression fractures treated with vertebroplasty. Using statistical models, the researchers compared this group's survival with that of 560 patients with similar lesions but without treatment. They found that 27% of the treated patients died within 2.2 years after fracture diagnosis compared with 9.4% of the untreated patients within 9.7 years of diagnosis.
The difference was statistically significant (p<0.0001).
McDonald noted that age and gender differences could account for some of the difference. Patients in the treated group were older (mean age 75 versus 68) and included more women. There were also significant differences in follow-up times between the two groups.
The project is still a work-in-progress, and interpretation of results may change when the researchers complete the analysis in the next few months. They are concerned that people may come to the wrong conclusions, such as that vertebroplasty is dangerous and should not be performed, McDonald said.
"Patient safety is our number one priority. But until we can confirm our results, they may not accurately reflect the impact vertebroplasty has on survival, if any," McDonald said.
For more information from the Diagnostic Imaging archives:
Imaging guidance prevents complications in vertebroplastyOsteoplasty holds promise for repair of bone fracturesHigh-tech suite of the future integrates imaging, roboticsMSK imaging, intervention head for explosive growth
Stay at the forefront of radiology with the Diagnostic Imaging newsletter, delivering the latest news, clinical insights, and imaging advancements for today’s radiologists.
Large Medicare Study Shows Black Men Less Likely to Receive PET and MRI for Prostate Cancer Imaging
August 4th 2025An analysis of over 749,000 Medicare beneficiaries diagnosed with prostate cancer over a five-year period found that Black men were 13 percent less likely to receive PET imaging and 16 percent less likely to receive MRI in comparison to White men.
The Reading Room Podcast: Current and Emerging Insights on Abbreviated Breast MRI, Part 3
August 4th 2025In the last of a three-part podcast episode, Stamatia Destounis, MD, Emily Conant, MD and Habib Rahbar, MD, share additional insights on practical considerations and potential challenges in integrating abbreviated breast MRI into clinical practice, and offer their thoughts on future research directions.
The Reading Room Podcast: A Closer Look at Remote MRI Safety, Part 3
August 4th 2025In the third of a three-part podcast episode, Emanuel Kanal, M.D. and Tobias Gilk, MRSO, MRSE, discuss strategies for maintaining the integrity of time-out procedures and communication with remote MRI scanning.
Study Reveals Significant Prevalence of Abnormal PET/MRI and Dual-Energy CT Findings with Long Covid
August 4th 2025In a prospective study involving nearly 100 patients with Long Covid, 57 percent of patients had PET/MRI abnormalities and 90 percent of the cohort had abnormalities on dual-energy CT scans.