Paper charges MR scam in CON states

Article

MRI manufacturers often pointto the capital acquisition thresholds present in various statecertificate-of-need systems when they price their low-end scannersunder $1 million. Do vendors, however, deliberately manipulatesystem prices in order to help

MRI manufacturers often pointto the capital acquisition thresholds present in various statecertificate-of-need systems when they price their low-end scannersunder $1 million. Do vendors, however, deliberately manipulatesystem prices in order to help particular customers avoid a CONreview? This was one of the charges leveled last month in an investigativeseries by The Plain Dealer of Cleveland, entitled "Imagesof Deceit."

The newspaper's MRI expose centered around "millionaireradiologist" Dr. James V. Zelch, an entrepreneurial physicianwith interest in a network of MR centers, primarily in the Clevelandarea. Zelch is a regular contributor to SCAN's sister publication,MR.

The Plain Dealer charged that Zelch repeatedly supplied Ohioand other state authorities with misleading information on newMRI projects, either low-balling the value or indicating disingenuouslythat the installation was for his private office, in order toavoid CON review.

In two examples cited by the paper, MRI supplier Hitachi wastied to the low-balling allegations made against Zelch. In oneinstance, Ohio's health director, Dr. Peter Somani, said he wasinitially inclined not to provide Zelch with a CON exemption fora Hitachi installation but changed his mind.

The state official could not understand at first how Zelchmight claim a sub-million-dollar price for the site "becauseZelch planned to install a powerful MRI machine that normallywould cost $2 million," the paper said.

After Hitachi supplied a list of five other instances whenthe same type of MR system was "purchased or offered"for under $1 million, Somani went ahead and granted the CON exemption,the paper said. But The Plain Dealer checked into the five examplesand found only one center that actually bought the Hitachi systemfor under $1 million.

The Plain Dealer then cited an out-of-state physician who boughta Hitachi system and was surprised to find that the vendor "wasselling their $1.3 million machine for $500,000 less to Zelchin Ohio."

This physician speculated to the paper that MRI suppliers mightprovide a "not fully functional" system without allits components in order to help a customer avoid a CON problem.

While much of the expose in the The Plain Dealer centers aroundCON review avoidance, the paper also lumps in self-referral abuseproblems. At times, it appears to confuse the two regulatory issues.The paper also does not clearly distinguish between referring-physicianand radiologist ownership of imaging centers.

"Ohio's system to control health-care costs by eliminatingpurchases of unnecessary high-tech medical equipment doesn't work,"said The Plain Dealer. "Instead, the system's shortcomingshave allowed huge medical profits because doctors who build centersto which they refer patients order more scans and make more money."

After surveying 24 states with laws against referring-physicianownership of medical centers, The Plain Dealer claimed that "Nodoctor has been prosecuted for violating any of the dozens ofso-called `self-referral' laws."

Newsletter

Stay at the forefront of radiology with the Diagnostic Imaging newsletter, delivering the latest news, clinical insights, and imaging advancements for today’s radiologists.

Recent Videos
SNMMI: Emerging PET Insights on Neuroinflammation with Progressive Apraxia of Speech (PAOS) and Parkinson-Plus Syndrome
Improving Access to Nuclear Imaging: An Interview with SNMMI President Jean-Luc C. Urbain, MD, PhD
SNMMI: 18F-Piflufolastat PSMA PET/CT Offers High PPV for Local PCa Recurrence Regardless of PSA Level
SNMMI: NIH Researcher Discusses Potential of 18F-Fluciclovine for Multiple Myeloma Detection
SNMMI: What Tau PET Findings May Reveal About Modifiable Factors for Alzheimer’s Disease
Emerging Insights on the Use of FES PET for Women with Lobular Breast Cancer
Can Generative AI Reinvent Radiology Reporting?: An Interview with Samir Abboud, MD
Mammography Study Reveals Over Sixfold Higher Risk of Advanced Cancer Presentation with Symptom-Detected Cancers
Combining Advances in Computed Tomography Angiography with AI to Enhance Preventive Care
Study: MRI-Based AI Enhances Detection of Seminal Vesicle Invasion in Prostate Cancer
Related Content
© 2025 MJH Life Sciences

All rights reserved.