HI hurdles net-tangible-asset rule

Article

Few publicly held imaging services firms will find shelter fromHeath and Human Services antifraud investigation under the $50million net-tangible-assets safe harbor, according to Robert D.Carl, president and CEO of center firm Health Images of Atlanta.

Few publicly held imaging services firms will find shelter fromHeath and Human Services antifraud investigation under the $50million net-tangible-assets safe harbor, according to Robert D.Carl, president and CEO of center firm Health Images of Atlanta.

In fact, Carl suspects HI may be the only imaging firm to qualify.

While SCAN listed several public imaging services firms withinreach of $50 million in total assets in our last issue, the safe-harborasset target is harder to reach when both good will and debt aresubtracted to meet the net-tangible-asset qualification, he said.

HHS has allowed firms to add back to their assets the depreciatedvalue of medical equipment. Even this break, however, will notbring the asset goal within reach of most companies, Carl said.

"Health Images absolutely does (meet the asset criteria).We have the best balance sheet in the industry and the highesttangible net worth," he said. "Our tangible net worthwould be $71 million before adjusting for depreciation."

If Carl's stance is correct, HI will have a competitive advantagein scooping up independent MRI centers seeking to escape frompotential antifraud prosecution. It is too early to predict howmany centers will seek this way out, Carl told SCAN.

"The initial response (to the safe-harbor regulations)may be (for centers) to put their heads in the sand and hope toget by without Medicare patients. But I don't think that is goingto work in the long run," he said. Avoidance of restrictionson referring-physician ownership in medical centers will becomeharder if private insurance groups follow the HHS lead.

The Office of the Inspector General within HHS is likely togive centers until the end of this year to respond to the safeharbors, Carl said.

"My feeling is that after the beginning of the year, weare going to see significant prosecution taking place. OIG willgo after the more abusive self-referral kickback schemes,"he said.

HI is not immune from the need to restructure to fulfill safeharbor criteria, Carl said. Some of its centers have about 10%ownership by referring physicians. In these cases, HI may be consideredas an investor in a partially referring-physician-owned centerthat:

  • is in a position to control or influence referralsthrough its marketing efforts; and

  • owns over 40% of center equity.

Hospitals that run ventures with minority physician partnerscould be in a similar bind. They may lay outside the safe harborrequirement that 60% of equity in physician joint ventures beheld by nonreferring investors, Carl said.

Since physician investment at HI is so low, it is doubtfulthat HHS would investigate, even though there might be a technicalviolation. In any case, buying out its physicians would not havea material affect on HI operations, he said.

Newsletter

Stay at the forefront of radiology with the Diagnostic Imaging newsletter, delivering the latest news, clinical insights, and imaging advancements for today’s radiologists.

Recent Videos
SNMMI: Emerging PET Insights on Neuroinflammation with Progressive Apraxia of Speech (PAOS) and Parkinson-Plus Syndrome
Improving Access to Nuclear Imaging: An Interview with SNMMI President Jean-Luc C. Urbain, MD, PhD
SNMMI: 18F-Piflufolastat PSMA PET/CT Offers High PPV for Local PCa Recurrence Regardless of PSA Level
SNMMI: NIH Researcher Discusses Potential of 18F-Fluciclovine for Multiple Myeloma Detection
SNMMI: What Tau PET Findings May Reveal About Modifiable Factors for Alzheimer’s Disease
Emerging Insights on the Use of FES PET for Women with Lobular Breast Cancer
Can Generative AI Reinvent Radiology Reporting?: An Interview with Samir Abboud, MD
Mammography Study Reveals Over Sixfold Higher Risk of Advanced Cancer Presentation with Symptom-Detected Cancers
Combining Advances in Computed Tomography Angiography with AI to Enhance Preventive Care
Study: MRI-Based AI Enhances Detection of Seminal Vesicle Invasion in Prostate Cancer
Related Content
© 2025 MJH Life Sciences

All rights reserved.